Difficult Conversations
Difficult conversations involve you giving, receiving, or discussing critical performance feedback. Open communication should go both ways, not just from leaders down to employees. This articles provides tips for handling difficult conversations.
Difficult Conversations
Difficult conversations involve you giving, receiving, or discussing critical performance feedback. Difficult conversations typically are top down but can also happen bottom up. Open communication should go both ways, not just from leaders down to employees
Top-down: A manager, boss, or leader initiates a difficult conversation with an employee or someone they supervise. Example: A manager talks to an employee about poor performance or inappropriate behavior.
Bottom-up: An employee or someone in a lower position initiates a difficult conversation with a manager or leader. Example: An employee tells their boss they feel unfairly treated, raises concerns about leadership, or asks for changes in the workplace.
Difficult conversations can be challenging because delivering negative or critical feedback can be uncomfortable, particularly when the other person becomes emotional, defensive, or resistant to the information being shared. There may also be concerns about causing conflict, damaging relationships, or being misunderstood.
Engaging in difficult conversations is important to resolve issues and avoid bigger problems in the future. Additionally, it gives the parties an opportunity to address whatever the problem may be. Either the manager or employee does not know that their behavior is having a negative impact or that they are performing poorly.
A difficult conversation does not have to be completed in one sitting. The objective is not for one party to ‘win’; it is to address the issue fairly, protect everyone involved, and establish an appropriate way to move forward.
|
Checklist for Handling Difficult Conversations |
|
|
Top-down: Manager or leader speaking to an employee |
Bottom-up: Employee speaking to a manager or leader |
|
· Preparation, discussion and follow-up · Prepare the facts and clarify the purpose of the conversation. · Choose a private, appropriate time and place. · Explain the concern clearly and respectfully. · Describe specific behaviors or situations rather than making it personal. · Listen to the employee’s perspective without interrupting. · Acknowledge emotions and respond calmly to defensiveness or disagreement. · Agree on actions, expectations and any support needed. · Summarize agreed next steps and arrange a follow-up.
|
· Preparation, discussion and follow-up · Clarify the issue and what you want to achieve. · Gather relevant facts and examples. · Request a suitable time to speak privately. · Explain your concern respectfully and clearly. · Describe the impact on your work, wellbeing or team. · Listen to the manager’s perspective and ask questions. · Suggest practical solutions or changes where appropriate. · Agree on next steps and follow up if needed. |
Helpful reminders for both
- Stay calm: Focus on the issue, not the person.
- Be respectful: Avoid blame, assumptions and personal criticism.
- Listen actively: Allow each person to explain their perspective.
- Be open-minded: Be willing to consider different viewpoints.
- Focus on solutions: Aim for understanding and constructive action.
- Maintain confidentiality: Share sensitive information only with appropriate people.
In situations where someone involved in the difficult conversation has become highly emotional, aggressive, threatening, refuses to engage, or the conversation breaks down. Both parties should prioritize safety, remain professional and take a break and resume the conversation at another time.
|
Checklist for Handling Extreme Difficult Conversations |
|
|
Top-down: Manager or leader speaking to an employee |
Bottom-up: Employee speaking to a manager or leader |
|
· If the employee becomes emotional: Remain calm, acknowledge their feelings, and offer a short break.
· If the employee becomes defensive or refuses feedback: Listen to their concerns, clarify the facts, and avoid arguing or escalating the disagreement.
· If the employee becomes verbally aggressive: Set clear boundaries about respectful communication and pause the conversation if necessary.
· If the employee becomes threatening or violent: End the conversation, move to safety, and follow workplace security or emergency procedures.
· If no agreement can be reached: Document relevant facts, explain the next steps, and involve HR or another appropriate manager.
|
· If the manager becomes defensive: Remain professional, restate the concern using specific examples, and avoid making the discussion personal.
· If the manager dismisses or interrupts concerns: Ask to finish explaining, clarify the key issue, and request a further meeting if needed.
· If the manager becomes intimidating or verbally aggressive: Set respectful boundaries and end or pause the conversation if it is no longer productive.
· If the manager threatens, harasses, or retaliates: Prioritize safety, keep a factual record of relevant incidents, and seek appropriate support through HR, or a higher-level manager.
· If the issue remains unresolved: Use the College’s escalation process, as appropriate. · After the conversation: Confirm key points and agreed actions in writing when appropriate. |
Helpful reminders for both
- Pause the conversation
If emotions are too high, suggest a break and reschedule a time to resume the conversation. Do not force the conversation to continue. Seek assistance from Human Resources
- Prioritize safety
If there is a credible threat, intimidation, or risk of violence, disengage and seek immediate help. Contact Public Safety, Human Resources, or 911.
- Record the facts
Document what happened, when it occurred, who was present, and any agreed actions. Avoid speculation or inflammatory language.
- Seek appropriate support
Involve Human Resources, a senior leader, or the Employee Assistance Program (EAP) or security depending on the situation.